The Difference Between Prepared Rehmannia Root and Processed Polygonum Multiflorum
The differences between Shu Di Huang (processed Rehmannia root) and Zhi Shou Wu (processed Polygonum multiflorum root) generally lie in their sources and processing methods, physical appearance, taste and channel tropism, therapeutic effects and indications, as well as clinical applications.
1. Source and Processing Methods: Shu Di Huang is the tuberous root of Rehmannia glutinosa that has undergone processing, typically involving steaming with yellow rice wine. Zhi Shou Wu is the tuberous root of Polygonum multiflorum processed by steaming with black soybean juice. Their sources and processing techniques differ, leading to variations in their medicinal properties and effects.
2. Physical Appearance: Shu Di Huang appears as irregular slices or fragments, with a black, glossy surface and a soft, moist texture. Zhi Shou Wu is in irregular blocky or spindle shapes, with a blackish-brown or dark brown surface marked by uneven longitudinal wrinkles. It has a firm texture and a horny, dark brown to black cross-section.
3. Taste, Property, and Channel Tropism: Shu Di Huang is sweet in taste and slightly warm in property, acting on the liver and kidney meridians. Zhi Shou Wu is bitter, sweet, and astringent in taste, also slightly warm, affecting the liver, heart, and kidney meridians. Compared to Shu Di Huang, Zhi Shou Wu involves an additional meridian—the heart—and its bitter and astringent qualities lead to differing therapeutic focuses.
4. Therapeutic Effects and Indications: Shu Di Huang mainly nourishes yin, enriches blood, and replenishes essence and marrow. It is used for conditions such as liver and kidney yin deficiency and blood deficiency with sallow complexion. Zhi Shou Wu primarily nourishes the liver and kidneys, enriches essence and blood, darkens hair, strengthens tendons and bones, and helps lower lipid levels. It is commonly used for various disorders caused by liver-kidney deficiency and insufficiency of essence and blood, particularly showing unique effects in darkening hair and reducing lipids.
5. Clinical Applications: Shu Di Huang is frequently used in treating gynecological disorders such as menstrual irregularities and infertility, and is a key herb for nourishing yin and tonifying the kidneys. Zhi Shou Wu is commonly used for hair loss, premature graying, and hyperlipidemia. It is widely applied in health preservation and treating chronic conditions, such as delaying aging and improving lipid metabolism disorders.
In traditional Chinese medicine theory, Shu Di Huang and Zhi Shou Wu have different focuses. Proper differentiation and treatment according to syndrome patterns are essential. Before using any of these herbs, consultation with a qualified TCM practitioner is necessary to ensure safety and efficacy.