Which is more effective: stapler circumcision or laser circumcision?
Sep 20, 2024
Source: Cainiu Health
Dr. Yang Ziqi
Introduction
Generally speaking, it is not appropriate to ask which is better between stapler circumcision and laser circumcision. The term "stapler" refers specifically to the circumcision stapler device. Circumcision staplers are suitable for patients with mild penile adhesions and no severe inflammation. Laser circumcision, on the other hand, is more appropriate for patients who have higher aesthetic expectations or desire a minimally invasive procedure. Both laser circumcision and stapler circumcision have their own advantages and limitations.
In general, it is not appropriate to ask which is better between stapler circumcision and laser circumcision. The term "stapler" refers specifically to the preputial stapler device. The preputial stapler is suitable for patients with mild adhesions and no severe inflammation, while laser circumcision is more appropriate for patients who have higher aesthetic expectations or desire a minimally invasive procedure.
Item |
Preputial Stapler |
Laser Circumcision |
Principle |
Removal of part of the foreskin to expose the glans penis |
Use of low-energy CO2 laser instead of traditional scalpel to remove excess foreskin |
Indications |
Phimosis, recurrent infections due to long foreskin, paraphimosis, thickened foreskin |
Long foreskin, phimosis, recurrent balanitis |
Reference Price |
1,000–3,000 RMB per session |
3,000–6,000 RMB per session |
| Duration of Effect | 3–7 years | 3–5 years |
Advantages |
1. Short operation time: 10–30 minutes 2. Minimal bleeding 3. Neat wound edges |
1. Simple procedure 2. Faster recovery: 7–20 days |
Potential Risks |
1. Slow wound healing: 10–30 days 2. Skin necrosis at wound edge |
1. Irregular wound edges 2. Postoperative bleeding |
Both laser circumcision and preputial stapler techniques have their respective advantages and limitations. When choosing a surgical method, patients should fully understand their condition and make a comprehensive decision based on professional medical advice.
